SHAWNDUNCANBusiness CoachBook
ProfitSeptember 13, 20267 min read

What Owning Businesses Taught Me About Profitability

Nobody teaches owners the math that actually decides whether the year was worth it. Here is what two decades of running my own companies taught me the expensive way.

The short version

  • 01Profit is a pricing and labor decision long before it is a cost-cutting decision.
  • 02Gross margin tells you whether the work is worth doing; net profit tells you whether the company is worth owning.
  • 03Cutting expenses has a floor. Pricing does not.
  • 04Cash flow and profit are different problems and need different fixes.
  • 05If the owner is not paid a market wage, the profit number is fiction.

I did not learn profitability in a classroom. I learned it by having a great year on paper and an empty account in December.

Here is what actually stuck after two decades of owning and operating.

Revenue tells you nothing on its own

The first lesson, and the most expensive one. A business can grow revenue every single year and get worse every single year. More revenue means more labor, more materials, more admin, more risk, more mess. If the margin on that revenue is thin, growth just scales the thinness.

I have run a bigger, busier, more impressive-looking version of a company that made me less money than the smaller version did.

Gross margin is the honest number

Gross margin — what is left after the direct cost of delivering the work — is the fastest read on whether a job, a service line, or a customer is worth having.

Say you sell a job for $1,000 and the labor and materials to deliver it cost $650. That is $350 of gross margin, 35%. Now out of every $350 you have to pay rent, insurance, the truck, the software, the office person, marketing, and yourself. Run the math on how many of those jobs you need before anything is left. Most owners have never run it, which is why they say yes to work that loses money in a suit.

Cutting expenses has a floor. Pricing does not.

Every owner's first instinct when profit is bad is to cut. Cancel subscriptions, shop insurance, squeeze a vendor. Fine — do it once a year. But there is a hard bottom to that game, and you hit it fast.

Pricing has no ceiling in the same way. On a business doing $1M at a 10% net, a 5% price increase that you do not lose volume over is $50,000 straight to the bottom line. There is no expense audit on earth that finds you $50,000 in a $1M company. That is not a trick. That is arithmetic most owners are too nervous to do.

Labor percentage is where the money quietly leaves

In service businesses, labor is usually the largest controllable cost and the least controlled. Not because people are overpaid — because the work is unscheduled, unmeasured, and re-done.

Track labor as a percentage of revenue, weekly. Not monthly, weekly. The month is too late to fix anything. When that number drifts two or three points and stays there, you have just given away your entire net profit and you will not feel it until the year is over.

Cash flow and profit are separate problems

Profitable companies go broke. It happens constantly. You can have a great margin and still be out of cash because customers pay in sixty days and payroll runs every two weeks.

Treat them as two different dashboards. Profit answers "is this business worth running." Cash answers "can this business survive until Friday." Fixing one does not fix the other.

Pay yourself a market wage or your numbers are fiction

This one took me too long. If you are working full time in the business and paying yourself whatever is left over, you do not know if the business is profitable. You know that you are subsidizing it with unpaid labor.

Put a real wage for your role in the expenses. What would you have to pay someone to do your job. If the company is still profitable after that, you own a business. If it is not, you bought a job with a lot of extra risk attached.

The habit that changed everything

I stopped asking "how was the month" and started asking three questions, every week:

  • What did we sell, and at what margin?
  • What did labor cost as a percentage of that?
  • What is in the bank, and what is committed out of it?

Fifteen minutes. That is it. Almost every profit disaster I have ever had or watched was visible in those three numbers weeks before it showed up in the bank account.

What to fix first

If you do one thing after reading this, compute your gross margin by service line for the last twelve months. Not overall — by line. You will find at least one thing you have been selling enthusiastically that has been quietly funding itself with your own money.

Run the numbers

Put your own numbers in

All free calculators →

Want this run on your actual numbers?

A Growth Assessment looks at the whole business, finds what's really limiting it, and tells you what to fix first.

Schedule Your Growth Assessment

Keep reading

All posts →

Browse by topic